ATi Catalyst 3.2 - 5.3 Treiber-Vergleich

17. Januar 2005, mit Update vom 20. Mai 2005 / von Raff / Seite 33 von 39

Benchmarks Unreal Tournament 2003 (Forts.)

	Unreal Tournament 2003 1600x1200 kein AA/AF
	Athlon XP Thoroughbred @ 2308 MHz - Radeon 9800 Pro @ 425/370 MHz


Catalyst 5.3					43,6 fps


Catalyst 5.2					43,6 fps


Catalyst 5.1					43,1 fps


Catalyst 4.12					43,8 fps


Catalyst 4.12b					43,8 fps


Catalyst 4.11					43,2 fps


Catalyst 4.10					43,0 fps


Catalyst 4.9					43,3 fps


Catalyst 4.8					42,6 fps


Catalyst 4.7					42,7 fps


Catalyst 4.6					42,2 fps


Catalyst 4.5					9,7 fps


Catalyst 4.4					14,3 fps


Catalyst 4.3					6,7 fps


Catalyst 4.2					29,1 fps


Catalyst 4.1					42,6 fps


Catalyst 3.10					46,0 fps


Catalyst 3.9					46,6 fps


Catalyst 3.8					15,7 fps


Catalyst 3.7					47,3 fps


Catalyst 3.6					47,1 fps


Catalyst 3.5					46,9 fps


Catalyst 3.4					47,1 fps


Catalyst 3.2					36,4 fps

7 fps

14 fps

21 fps

28 fps

35 fps

42 fps

49 fps

56 fps

	Unreal Tournament 2003 1600x1200 16xTriAF
	Athlon XP Thoroughbred @ 2308 MHz - Radeon 9800 Pro @ 425/370 MHz


Catalyst 5.3					28,8 fps


Catalyst 5.2					28,8 fps


Catalyst 5.1					28,6 fps


Catalyst 4.12					28,8 fps


Catalyst 4.12b					28,8 fps


Catalyst 4.11					28,7 fps


Catalyst 4.10					28,8 fps


Catalyst 4.9					27,4 fps


Catalyst 4.8					28,8 fps


Catalyst 4.7					28,8 fps


Catalyst 4.6					29,0 fps


Catalyst 4.5					8,5 fps


Catalyst 4.4					11,7 fps


Catalyst 4.3					18,4 fps


Catalyst 4.2					20,1 fps


Catalyst 4.1					30,0 fps


Catalyst 3.10					30,3 fps


Catalyst 3.9					30,2 fps


Catalyst 3.8					13,3 fps


Catalyst 3.7					30,7 fps


Catalyst 3.6					30,7 fps


Catalyst 3.5					30,1 fps


Catalyst 3.4					30,4 fps


Catalyst 3.2					31,8 fps

7 fps

14 fps

21 fps

28 fps

35 fps

42 fps

49 fps

56 fps

	Unreal Tournament 2003 1600x1200 2xAA/16xTriAF
	Athlon XP Thoroughbred @ 2308 MHz - Radeon 9800 Pro @ 425/370 MHz


Catalyst 5.3					25,9 fps


Catalyst 5.2					25,3 fps


Catalyst 5.1					25,3 fps


Catalyst 4.12					22,4 fps


Catalyst 4.12b					22,5 fps


Catalyst 4.11					22,6 fps


Catalyst 4.10					22,5 fps


Catalyst 4.9					22,9 fps


Catalyst 4.8					22,7 fps


Catalyst 4.7					22,3 fps


Catalyst 4.6					22,9 fps


Catalyst 4.5					7,9 fps


Catalyst 4.4					10,5 fps


Catalyst 4.3					15,9 fps


Catalyst 4.2					17,1 fps


Catalyst 4.1					23,8 fps


Catalyst 3.10					25,4 fps


Catalyst 3.9					25,4 fps


Catalyst 3.8					13,4 fps


Catalyst 3.7					27,1 fps


Catalyst 3.6					27,2 fps


Catalyst 3.5					23,7 fps


Catalyst 3.4					23,9 fps


Catalyst 3.2					24,8 fps

7 fps

14 fps

21 fps

28 fps

35 fps

42 fps

49 fps

56 fps

	Unreal Tournament 2003 1600x1200 4xAA/16xTriAF
	Athlon XP Thoroughbred @ 2308 MHz - Radeon 9800 Pro @ 425/370 MHz


Catalyst 5.3					23,2 fps


Catalyst 5.2					21,0 fps


Catalyst 5.1					20,9 fps


Catalyst 4.12					20,1 fps


Catalyst 4.12b					20,1 fps


Catalyst 4.11					20,0 fps


Catalyst 4.10					20,3 fps


Catalyst 4.9					20,4 fps


Catalyst 4.8					20,1 fps


Catalyst 4.7					20,2 fps


Catalyst 4.6					20,1 fps


Catalyst 4.5					7,6 fps


Catalyst 4.4					10,0 fps


Catalyst 4.3					14,8 fps


Catalyst 4.2					15,8 fps


Catalyst 4.1					20,7 fps


Catalyst 3.10					21,4 fps


Catalyst 3.9					20,8 fps


Catalyst 3.8					14,1 fps


Catalyst 3.7					21,8 fps


Catalyst 3.6					21,5 fps


Catalyst 3.5					21,2 fps


Catalyst 3.4					21,7 fps


Catalyst 3.2					21,8 fps

7 fps

14 fps

21 fps

28 fps

35 fps

42 fps

49 fps

56 fps

	Unreal Tournament 2003 1600x1200 6xAA/16xTriAF
	Athlon XP Thoroughbred @ 2308 MHz - Radeon 9800 Pro @ 425/370 MHz


Catalyst 5.3					15,9 fps


Catalyst 5.2					15,9 fps


Catalyst 5.1					16,0 fps


Catalyst 4.12					16,1 fps


Catalyst 4.12b					16,2 fps


Catalyst 4.11					16,0 fps


Catalyst 4.10					15,9 fps


Catalyst 4.9					16,0 fps


Catalyst 4.8					16,1 fps


Catalyst 4.7					15,9 fps


Catalyst 4.6					17,3 fps


Catalyst 4.5					7,1 fps


Catalyst 4.4					9,1 fps


Catalyst 4.3					13,5 fps


Catalyst 4.2					14,4 fps


Catalyst 4.1					17,6 fps


Catalyst 3.10					17,1 fps


Catalyst 3.9					17,1 fps


Catalyst 3.8					12,8 fps


Catalyst 3.7					17,9 fps


Catalyst 3.6					18,0 fps


Catalyst 3.5					17,2 fps


Catalyst 3.4					17,1 fps


Catalyst 3.2					17,6 fps

7 fps

14 fps

21 fps

28 fps

35 fps

42 fps

49 fps

56 fps

Die Catalysts der 4er-Reihe brechen im Vergleich zu ihren 3er-Kollegen teils stark ein. Eine Diskrepanz ergibt sich bei den 1600er-Werten des 4.3: Er ist ohne AA/AF wahrhaft unterirdisch langsam, mit 16xTriAF verdreifachen sich die Frames. Allgemein scheinen er sowie die Cats 4.4 & 4.5 Probleme mit dem Spiel zu haben, die ab Version 4.6 wieder aus der Treiberwelt geschafft werden.

Interessantes Detail am Rande: Wie uns Terry "Catalyst Maker" Makedon mitteilte, erkennt ATis neueste Treiber-Errungenschaft "A.I." Unreal Tournament 2003 und optimiert das Texturmanagement. Die Werte der Catalysts ab Version 4.10 zeigen jedoch eindrucksvoll, dass davon unter OpenGL nichts zu sehen ist.

ATi Catalyst 3.2 - 5.3 Treiber-Vergleich

ATiCatalyst 3.2 - 5.3 Treiber-Vergleich

ATi
Catalyst 3.2 - 5.3 Treiber-Vergleich